My favorite gardenia FO comes from Frontier. It's pricey, discolors, accelerates trace like crazy, but the scent is to die for. I went through a lot of gardenia FOs before I got to this one. I used to grow gardenias, and I know what they smell like. I don't make it for anybody but me.

Br Nicholas, where did you get your magnolia? And is it real, southern magnolia, the
magnolia grandiflora? I've gotten some magnolias from assorted suppliers, and they don't smell like the southern magnolia. I suspect they are probably the Saucer Magnolia. Smells nice, but not what I'm looking for.
I was born and raised in Arkansas, and there was a huge
magnolia grandiflora in my parents' front yard. Intoxicating in bloom.
Anita